Drive one lap around I-465 and try to count the injury lawyer billboards. You will lose track before you pass the airport. A billboard gives you a phone number. It does not tell you who picks up, who goes to trial, or who settles cheap to clear a desk.
So we looked past the ads. Case results, years in practice, review counts, and peer ratings all went into this list. Seven Indianapolis firms made the cut.
Key Takeaway
Hurst Limontes LLC is the best car accident firm in Indianapolis for 2026. The downtown firm has handled injury cases since 1981. Its named partners hold AV Preeminent ratings. Its results include a $12 million bus crash settlement and a $6.5 million truck crash settlement. The team serves clients in Spanish and answers calls 24/7. If you want one name to call first, start here. If your case has an unusual angle, one of the other six firms may fit better.
Indianapolis Car Accident Firms at a Glance
| Firm | Best For | Experience | Reviews and Recognition | Notable Result or Feature | Office |
| Hurst Limontes LLC | Serious crashes, disputed fault, Spanish-speaking clients | Since 1981, 116+ years combined | AV Preeminent, Best Law Firms 2026, 5.0 on FindLaw (489 reviews) | $12M bus crash settlement | Downtown, S. Meridian St. |
| Keller & Keller | Crashes that need reconstruction | Family-run since 1936 | 90+ years in Indiana courts | Drone and reconstruction tools | N. Meridian St. |
| Yosha Law | Truck and rideshare collisions | Since 1963, 172 years combined | 5.0 on Google (135 reviews) | Commercial vehicle focus | North Meridian corridor |
| Eskew Law, LLC | Pedestrians, passengers, and injured drivers | Christopher Eskew, 20 years | 4.6 on Google (217 reviews), 4.9 on Avvo (46 reviews) | Settlements and trial wins | Downtown, N. Alabama St. |
| Marc Lopez Law Firm | Fast intake, bilingual service | High-volume auto injury practice | 4.9 on Google (1,588 reviews) | Former insurance defense attorney on staff | Downtown, E. Market St. |
| Garrison Law Firm, LLC | Crashes that need a prosecutor’s eye for evidence | Chris Garrison, 43 years | Former deputy prosecutor leads the firm | Father-and-son practice | Castleton area |
| Cohen & Malad, LLP | Brain injury after a crash | Since 1968 | 5.0 on Google (163 reviews) | Partner on Brain Injury Association of America executive committee | One Indiana Square |
How These Seven Got Picked
Every firm here treats car crashes as core work, not a side service. Each one has offices in the Indianapolis area and history in Marion County courts. That matters in a city where the I-65 and I-70 splits, Keystone Avenue, and the Pike Township stretch of I-465 produce wrecks every week. Local lawyers know the local adjusters. They also know which ones bluff.
1. Hurst Limontes LLC
Bill Hurst opened this practice in 1981. Managing Partner Alex Limontes now leads a team of eight attorneys from an office a few blocks from the City-County Building. Hurst made the American Trial Lawyers Association Top 100 list in both 1998 and 2013. Both named partners appear in Best Lawyers in America.
The results tell you how the firm works. A police officer lost his memory of a red-light crash, and the insurer claimed its driver never ran the light. The Hurst Limontes team filed suit, tracked down witnesses, and settled for $800,000. Other wins include a $12 million bus crash settlement and a $6.2 million motorcycle settlement against a corporate truck.
The firm runs a Spanish-language site and supports clients in more than one language. It also works with the Indiana Fever on community projects.
Best for: serious crashes where the insurance company disputes fault, and families who want help in Spanish.
Address: 50 S. Meridian St., Suite 600, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 636-0808
Website: hurstlimontes.com
2. Keller & Keller
This family firm has worked Indiana cases since 1936. Its attorneys use accident reconstruction and drone footage to show exactly how a crash happened. That kind of proof helps when both drivers tell a different story.
The firm represents clients in a range of motor vehicle accidents, including car crashes, truck collisions, and other serious roadway incidents. Its experience with complex accident cases can help when liability is disputed or when the injuries involve substantial medical treatment and lost income. The attorneys also work with clients to pursue compensation for medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and other accident-related losses.
Best for: multi-car pileups and crashes with no clear witness.
Address: 2850 N. Meridian St., Indianapolis, IN 46208
Website: 2keller.com
3. Yosha Law
Yosha Law has represented injured Hoosiers since 1963, giving the firm decades of experience handling complex personal injury claims. Its lawyers bring more than 172 years of combined experience and represent clients in serious motor vehicle accidents throughout Indiana. The firm handles truck, commercial vehicle, rideshare, and other traffic-related crashes where determining who is responsible can become complicated.
Best for: a wreck involving a semi, a delivery van, or an Uber or Lyft driver.
Address: 280 E 96th St Ste 220A Indianapolis, IN 46260
Website: yoshalawfirm.com
4. Eskew Law, LLC
Christopher Eskew founded this downtown firm and has practiced for about 20 years. His team represents pedestrians, passengers, and drivers hurt by someone else’s mistake. The firm has won money through both settlements and trials. It also gives back, backing Sober Holiday Rides and Rock for Riley and funding a yearly scholarship for law students.
The attorneys handle cases involving serious injuries and work to identify the facts and insurance coverage that can affect a client’s claim. Its central Indianapolis location also makes it convenient for local clients who need to meet with the legal team.
Best for: a pedestrian struck downtown or a passenger hurt in someone else’s car.
Address: 255 N. Alabama St., 3rd Floor, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Website: eskewlaw.com
5. Rob King & Associates, Trial Lawyers
The firm puts “trial lawyers” right in its name, and that tells you how it plans to handle your case. Rob King and his team bring more than four decades of combined experience to car crashes, truck wrecks, catastrophic injuries, and wrongful death claims across Marion County. King holds an AV Preeminent rating from his peers, the top mark for legal skill and ethics.
The practice works only for injured people and their families. It does not split time with defense work or unrelated legal fields. Case evaluations are free, and the firm works on contingency, so you owe nothing unless it recovers money for you. Its office sits on East Washington Street, a short walk from Monument Circle.
Best for: a crash where the insurer won’t budge and the case may need a jury.
Address: 320 N Meridian St Ste 906, Indianapolis, IN 46204 | Phone: (317) 648-1339
6. Garrison Law Firm, LLC
Joseph Garrison founded this firm, and his son Chris now runs it as managing partner. Chris spent time as a deputy prosecutor before turning to injury work, and he has more than 40 years in practice. The team gathers evidence, finds eyewitnesses, and builds the facts of a crash from the ground up. It also handles wrongful death and dangerous product claims. That investigative approach can be particularly useful when fault is disputed or important evidence is difficult to locate. The firm represents clients in serious injury cases and works to determine the full impact of an accident on their lives.
Best for: a crash where the evidence is thin and someone needs to dig for it.
Address: 9795 Crosspoint Blvd., Suite 101, Indianapolis, IN 46256 | Website: garrisonlegal.com
7. Cohen & Malad, LLP
Cohen & Malad has served Indianapolis since 1968. Partner Daniel Chamberlain sits on the executive committee of the Brain Injury Association of America. That background helps when a crash leaves hidden damage that shows up weeks later. The firm handles serious personal injury claims and can help clients pursue compensation when an accident causes long-term physical or cognitive effects. Its Indianapolis office also provides a local option for families dealing with the financial and personal consequences of a major injury.
Best for: concussions and traumatic brain injuries after a wreck.
Address: One Indiana Square, Suite 1400, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Website: cohenandmalad.com
Before You Sign Anything
Ask three questions on the first call. Who will handle my file day to day? How many car crash cases did you take to trial last year? What percentage do you take, and does it go up if the case goes to court? A good firm answers all three without dodging.
FAQ
Q. How long do I have to file a car accident claim in Indiana?
Two years from the date of the crash for most injury claims. Miss it, and the court will likely toss your case.
Q. Can I still get paid if I was partly at fault?
Yes, as long as you were less than 51 percent at fault. Indiana cuts your award by your share of the blame.
Q. What if a city bus or government vehicle hit me?
You must file a written notice much sooner. Claims against a city or county need notice within 180 days. Claims against the state need notice within 270 days.
Q. What is the minimum car insurance in Indiana?
Drivers must carry $25,000 per person and $50,000 per crash for bodily injury, plus $25,000 for property damage. A serious crash can blow past those limits fast.
Q. How much does a car accident lawyer cost in Indianapolis?
Most work on contingency. You pay nothing up front, and the firm takes a cut of what it recovers. Get the percentage in writing.
Final Word
Every firm on this list can handle a car crash claim. Hurst Limontes earns the top spot because of its long track record, its trial-ready results, and a team that speaks your language. Call two or three firms, ask hard questions, and pick the lawyer who treats your case like it matters.
