The release of the Rev. Edward Nalwamba from immigration detention in Colorado in October 2026 put renewed attention on how long the government may hold someone when deportation cannot be arranged. Nalwamba, a 79-year-old pastor, had spent approximately 13 months in custody before a federal judge found that immigration authorities lacked a concrete plan to remove him to Uganda. His release addressed the legality of continued confinement, not a final grant of immigration status.
Who is Edward Nalwamba?

Nalwamba is a Ugandan-born clergyman associated with a Colorado Anglican congregation. He fled Uganda more than two decades ago and had lived in the United States for many years. Federal authorities said he overstayed his visa and resisted earlier directions to leave; he and supporters maintained that he had repeatedly tried to navigate the immigration system and obtain legal assistance.
Those competing accounts explain the dispute over his status. Neither long residence nor religious work automatically creates a right to remain permanently in the United States, but immigration violations also do not authorize limitless detention.
Why was he held for so long?
Immigration custody can continue after a final removal order while the government arranges travel documents and a receiving country. However, the government’s power is constrained by federal law and constitutional protections. In Nalwamba’s case, detention lasted about 13 months while removal to Uganda had not occurred.
The reported legal issue was not whether the government had ever issued a removal decision. It was whether continued custody remained justified when authorities could not demonstrate a realistic plan to carry it out.
What did the judge decide?
U.S. Magistrate Judge Cyrus Y. Chung ordered Nalwamba’s release in October. Reporting on the ruling says the judge found no concrete plan for deportation and that the detention exceeded the period generally presumed reasonable under Supreme Court precedent.
In Zadvydas v. Davis, the Supreme Court addressed detention after a removal order and recognized six months as a presumptively reasonable period. That does not create an automatic release date for every detainee. After that period, the analysis can turn on whether the person shows good reason to believe removal is not reasonably foreseeable and whether the government can rebut that showing.
A court’s release order does not erase an underlying removal order or turn the individual into a lawful permanent resident. It addresses custody under the legal circumstances presented.
Health concerns during detention
Supporters said Nalwamba lost considerable weight and eventually needed assistance walking. His church’s lead pastor also alleged that he had been ill and had not received adequate medical attention. The Department of Homeland Security disputed the allegation that it denied him treatment.
The reported disagreement should be described as such. Without medical records and a judicial finding on treatment, it would be misleading to claim that the government had been legally found responsible for specific medical injuries.
Immigration detention facilities are required to address health and safety needs, and allegations of neglect may be examined through grievances, oversight complaints and litigation where legally appropriate. Those are separate inquiries from the decision to release someone because deportation is not reasonably foreseeable.
What is the broader legal issue?
Post-removal-order detention differs from ordinary criminal punishment. Its purpose is generally to carry out removal rather than to sentence someone for an immigration offense. When that purpose cannot realistically be achieved, prolonged confinement may become legally vulnerable.
Attorneys evaluating such cases examine the removal order, detention timeline, government efforts to obtain travel documents, any delays attributable to the detainee and the receiving country’s position. The details can change whether a federal habeas corpus petition succeeds.
What happens after release?
Nalwamba’s release permitted him to leave the Aurora detention facility and return to supporters. It did not necessarily end all immigration obligations or prevent future lawful proceedings. The terms of release and any subsequent changes would need to be checked against the case record.
The ruling highlights an important limit: the federal government may pursue removal under immigration law, but it cannot assume that an unresolved deportation plan justifies detention without end.