A federal judge ordered immigration officials to release Canadian-born dentist William Virgil Lizardo on November 1, 2026, after a dispute over an immigration hearing notice and an arrest in Minnesota. The case attracted attention because Lizardo’s family said the government mailed a crucial notice to an address they no longer used. The court’s intervention addressed his detention; it did not automatically settle his application for permanent residence.
Who is William Virgil Lizardo?
Lizardo came to the United States in 2019 to attend the University of Minnesota School of Dentistry and completed his degree in 2023. He later married a U.S. citizen and pursued permanent residency. According to reporting based on court documents, a family-based immigration petition was approved, but his adjustment-of-status application encountered a problem involving documentation of a withdrawn Canadian legal matter.
The immigration process involves more than an approved family petition. A person generally must separately meet the requirements for adjustment of status or another form of lawful residence. A pending appeal or application is not itself a court order granting permanent resident status.
The missed hearing and ICE arrest

The government scheduled an immigration hearing for March 26, 2026, but the notice was reportedly sent to a former Virginia address. Lizardo’s wife said the couple had moved to Minnesota more than two years earlier and were using their current address in other immigration communications. An immigration judge entered a removal order after the missed hearing.
On October 23, authorities arrested Lizardo at an immigration appointment in St. Paul. ICE described the arrest as enforcement of a final removal order. His attorneys argued that he had not received meaningful notice and was being detained unlawfully.
A notice problem can be legally significant. Immigration law contains specific rules governing service, changes of address, hearings held in a person’s absence and motions to reopen. Whether a notice was legally adequate must be decided from the actual record, not merely by assuming that any mailing is sufficient.
What did the federal judge order?
Lizardo filed a habeas corpus petition in federal court on October 25. On November 1, U.S. District Judge Michael J. Davis granted relief and ordered that he be released by that evening. The order required authorities to return his personal belongings and release him on his own recognizance.
The court also barred the government from detaining, transferring or removing him again without first obtaining permission from that court under the conditions set out in the order. The docket shows subsequent activity, including a November 4 dismissal entry; the procedural record should be checked before describing the injunction as indefinitely unchanged.
These are extraordinary but fact-specific remedies. They do not mean every immigration detainee can secure the same result, or that a federal court has granted the individual lawful permanent resident status.
Why the constitutional issues mattered
Lizardo’s lawyers challenged the arrest and detention under the Fourth and Fifth Amendments. The Fourth Amendment protects against unreasonable seizures; the Fifth Amendment requires due process when the federal government deprives a person of liberty. A petition under 28 U.S.C. Section 2241 can provide a way to challenge the legality of federal custody.
Courts examine the statutory basis for detention, the governing immigration proceedings and the person’s opportunity to contest government action. An invalid or reopened removal order can materially change that analysis.
What the ruling does not decide
Release from ICE custody is not the same as winning a green-card case. Lizardo may still need to pursue the immigration application or related proceedings under the applicable rules. Nor does a court’s intervention necessarily decide whether a damages claim will succeed.
The case demonstrates why correct addresses, proper notice and access to judicial review matter. It also shows the need for precise legal reporting: the verified result was a federal release order, while the longer-term immigration outcome remained a separate issue as of early November 2026.